Letter 52: Nepotian, the nephew of Heliodorus (for whom see Letter XIV.), had, like his uncle, abandoned the military for the clerical calling, and was now a presbyter at Altinum, where Heliodorus was bishop. The letter is a systematic treatise on the duties of the clergy and on the rule of life which they ought to adopt. It had a great vogue, and called f...

JeromeNepotian|c. 387 AD|jerome
barbarian invasioneducation booksfamine plaguegrief deathhumorillnessimperial politicsmonasticismproperty economicsslavery captivitywomen
Barbarian peoples/invasions; Imperial politics; Travel & mobility
From: Jerome, priest and scholar in Bethlehem
To: Nepotian, priest in Altinum
Date: ~394 AD
Context: A systematic guide to the duties of clergy, famous for its devastating portraits of clerical vice — this letter made Jerome many enemies in Rome.

Nepotian,

You keep asking me, in letter after letter, to write you a practical guide to the clerical life — how a man who has left the world to become a monk or a priest should walk the straight path of Christ without stumbling into vice. When I was young, still burning with the first fires of youthful passion and trying to extinguish them in the harsh life of the desert, I wrote a letter to your uncle Heliodorus that was full of tears and rhetorical flourishes. I was young then, and I wrote like a young man — still glowing with the methods and maxims of my teachers. Now, however, my head is gray, my brow furrowed, my chin sags like a bull's dewlap, and as Virgil says, "the chilly blood stands still around my heart."

But that I may not seem to cite only pagan literature, listen to what Scripture teaches. David was once a warrior, but at seventy, age had so chilled him that nothing could make him warm. A young woman — Abishag the Shunammite — was found to sleep beside the king and warm his old body [1 Kings 1:1-4]. If you stick to the letter that kills [2 Corinthians 3:6], this sounds like a scene from a farce. A shivering old man is wrapped in blankets and can only get warm in a girl's arms. But Bathsheba was still alive. Abigail was still available. All his wives and concubines are rejected as cold, and only this one young woman's embrace brings warmth. Who is this Shunammite — this wife and maiden, so warm as to heat the cold, yet so holy as not to arouse desire? Let Solomon explain: "Get wisdom, get understanding... love her and she shall keep you. Wisdom is the principal thing" [Proverbs 4:5-7]. The Shunammite is wisdom herself — the warmth that never corrupts.

Now to the practical rules. Here is the first and most important: a clergyman who runs a business is a man who has risen from poverty to wealth — which is to say, from obscurity to shame. Avoid that transformation. Shun the pursuit of money as you would shun the plague.

A clergyman must not be a dinner guest too often, or a habitual visitor of great houses. Never let your table be laid more lavishly than others of your rank, and never dine alone with women — no matter how consecrated they may be. A young clergyman should not visit a widow or a virgin except in the company of his seniors. If you must call on women in their homes, bring a companion whose life gives you no reason for embarrassment. A reader, an acolyte, a psalm-singer — any of these can serve as your chaperone. We are not superior to the apostle Paul, who told Timothy: "Give no cause for the adversary to speak reproachfully" [1 Timothy 5:14].

Let your breath never smell of wine, lest the philosopher's rebuke be applied to you: "You are not offering me a kiss — you are pouring me a drink." Priests who reek of wine are condemned alike by the apostle and by common sense. The old law forbade the priests of Aaron to drink wine when about to enter the temple [Leviticus 10:9]. For us, who are always in the temple, the lesson is clear.

I must speak plainly about another matter. Some clergymen seek ordination as priests or deacons for one reason only: to gain freer access to women. Their whole concern is their wardrobe, their perfume, and whether their shoes are a tight enough fit. Their hair is curled with tongs, their fingers flash with rings, and they walk on tiptoe to keep their feet from getting wet. You would sooner take them for bridegrooms than for clergy. Some of them devote their entire lives to learning the names, the houses, and the habits of wealthy matrons.

Let me sketch for you — briefly, since this letter is already long — one specimen of this type. He rises with the sun, maps out the order of his morning calls, and takes the shortest route to each great house. He presses in uninvited, making himself nearly impossible to avoid. If he sees a cushion, a fine cloth, or any elegant household item, he praises it, handles it, and complains that he has nothing like it — until it is given to him outright. He accompanies ladies to their country estates, makes himself useful at every dinner, and has a gift for every occasion. He has a sharp tongue, knows all the gossip, and is the first to bring news and the last to leave a party. Such a man has risen to the rank of archdeacon, and I ask myself: by what merit?

There are others who covet the priesthood solely because it gives them the freedom to see women without restriction. They care only about their clothes, their grooming, and the freshness of their breath. They are more like suitors than shepherds.

On the other hand, I say this: respect the bishops and priests who are genuinely holy. Give to your bishop the obedience he deserves — he is your father in the faith. Let your bishop treat you as a son, not a slave. "An elder," says the apostle, "rebuke not, but entreat him as a father" [1 Timothy 5:1].

When you preach, do not seek applause but groans. Let the tears of your listeners be your praise. A preacher's words should be seasoned with Scripture, not with rhetorical fireworks. Avoid the kind of sermon that makes the audience clap. That is a sign of failure, not success. The best preaching produces not admiration but conviction.

Read constantly. Never let the book drop from your hand. Learn what you are going to teach. Hold fast the faithful word as you have been taught, so that you may be able to exhort and to convince those who contradict [Titus 1:9]. A priest who cannot defend the faith is not worthy of the name. It is disgraceful for a minister of Christ to answer questions about the law with quotations from Cicero.

I have targeted no individual. Not a name has been mentioned. My words are aimed at faults, not persons. If anyone recognizes himself in this description, he will have proven my point before he has even finished objecting to it.

Modern English rendering for readability. See the 19th-century translation or original Latin/Greek for scholarly use.

Related Letters