Letter 64: You asked why the righteous suffer, and there is no better place to begin than the book of Job.

Ambrose to Orontianus — greetings. You asked why the righteous suffer, and there is no better place to begin than the book of Job. Job was blameless (Job 1:1). God himself said so. And then God allowed Satan to destroy everything Job had — his children, his wealth, his health, his reputation. The suffering was not punishment; it was permitted for a purpose that Job could not see and that God chose not to explain. The friends of Job — Eliphaz, Bildad, Zophar — represent the most natural human response to suffering: "You must have done something wrong." Their theology is tidy: God rewards the good and punishes the wicked; therefore, if you are suffering, you must be wicked. It is a seductive logic, and it is wrong. Job's greatness lies in his refusal to accept that logic while simultaneously refusing to curse God. He is angry — the book is honest about this. He challenges God. He demands an explanation. He sits in his ashes and screams at the heavens. None of this is sin. The psalms are full of the same raw protest, and God does not condemn it. What God condemns is the false comfort of the friends — the men who came to console and stayed to accuse. "You are miserable comforters, all of you" (Job 16:2). The worst kind of cruelty is theology deployed against the suffering. When God finally speaks, he does not explain. He does not say "Here is why I allowed it." He says, in effect, "I am God, and you are not, and the universe operates on principles beyond your comprehension" (Job 38-41). This is not an evasion; it is the truth. The demand for a complete explanation of suffering is a demand to be God. Trust what you cannot understand, brother. It is the only honest option. Farewell.

NEW ADVENT: Home Search: Home Encyclopedia Summa Fathers Bible Library A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z -->Pope Leo Calls Bishops to Rome to Discuss Families, ‘Amoris Laetitia’ in October 100 Questions Jesus Asked and You Should Answer... Msgr. Charles Pope One of the bigger mistakes one can make is to read Scripture as a spectator, treating it as merely a collection of stories and events that took place thousands of years ago. While these are historical accounts, they are much more than that. Truth be told, these ancient stories are our stories. We are in the narrative. We are Abraham, Sarah, Moses, Deborah, Jeremiah, Ruth, Peter, Paul, Magdalene, Mother Mary... National Eucharistic Pilgrimage registration opens; schedule released... Rome’s Colosseum gets a fresh look that recreates the footprints of long-gone columns... We should take pleasure in working and resting kindly, in the ordinary things, in the this extraordinary home God has crafted for us... John Cuddeback Several principles that shape how I live I learned from Wendell Berry. He has an astounding share of common sense and an ability to cut through to what matters. He finds extraordinary beauty in the ordinary—often an ordinary that as a people we have set aside or lost. These days, ever darkening shadows in the world along with our own sufferings and those of the people closest to us can start to crush and overwhelm us... Lay Leader Who Criticized Cardinal Cupich Phased Out of Catholic Conference Board... Jonathan Liedl Nearly six months after publicly criticizing Cardinal Blase Cupich’s plan to give a “lifetime achievement” award to a pro-abortion-rights senator, a long-serving lay member of the Catholic Conference of Illinois (CCI) board of directors is being involuntarily phased out of his role. 100 Pop Songs Every Catholic Should Hear: ‘Ablaze’ by Alanis Morissette... Tim Clark This past month, my children had many occasions to hear me say things like, “Watch this!” and “Look at that!” In Virginia, the world was adorned in a frozen gown. And when something or someone is covered in white, it’s a sign to us that something awe-inspiring is happening. A baby is clothed with white in baptism. Little girls wear white gowns to receive their Lord for the first time in Holy Communion... Vatican Appeals Court Declares Mistrial in ‘Trial of the Century’ Against Cardinal Becciu... St. Patrick’s Breastplate and the Terrors of Mid-Lent... Elizabeth Scalia The effort is not confined to the season; in fits and starts I work at it during the year, but the task is always re-embraced in these dreary days when the weather goes fickle, and spring’s arrival seems like a trickster’s promise. Easter looks so far off, right now, because our Lenten practices, begun with such a sense of adventure and optimism... Pope Leo XIV to Accept Liberty Medal from Philadelphia’s National Constitution Center via Telecast on July 3... Pope Leo XIV Appeals for Ceasefire and Dialogue in Middle East War... Vatican Awaits Pope Leo’s Next Moves... Francis X. Rocca Lent at the Vatican this year feels like Advent in some ways, with the prevalent mood one of anticipation. People inside and around the institution are waiting, with varying degrees of curiosity and enthusiasm, for long-expected moves by Pope Leo XIV... This Sunday, Jesus Escaped Death Long Enough To Help Us See... Tom Hoopes Meeting God, really meeting him, makes life more beautiful, more noble, more exciting, and more fulfilling — but first it makes it harder. The two go together. Here are six takeaways for the Fourth Sunday of Lent, Year A, drawn from Sunday Readings columns at this site. First: The cure of the man born blind comes at a rough time in Jesus’s life... Why Does John’s Gospel Not Mention the Institution of the Eucharist? The Triumph of Sentimentality in the Church of England... What St. Frances of Rome Saw in Heaven... Pope Leo Calls Father Pierre al-Rahi, Maronite Priest Killed in Lebanon, ‘a True Shepherd’... NBC Poll: Pope Leo XIV Held in Highest Esteem Among Public Personalities... Ontario Offers Death as a Same-Day Service... Why Was St. John Henry Newman Called ‘the Most Dangerous Man in England?’... Pope Leo XIV Warns of Wider Middle East Conflict, Prays to Our Lady ‘That the Thunderous Sound of Bombs May Cease’... Pope Leo XIV Appoints Archbishop Gabriele Giordano Caccia as Apostolic Nuncio to the US... This Sunday, Jesus Meets Us at the Well To Give Us What We Are Missing... St. Longinus: The Centurion Who Pierced Christ’s Side... A Time to Build, Nice Things, and No Comment... What’s the Word for Forgetting Words? Is Conclave Secrecy Dead — and Does It Matter? Anthropic’s Break With the Pentagon Ignites AI Ethics Debate, Echoes Vatican Warnings... One Priest Can't Care For Thousands. So What Should A Parish Do? Dutch Museum Makes ‘Needle in a Haystack’ Confirmation of Rembrandt Painting... Striking the Rock: A Reflection on the Third Sunday of Lent... USCCB President Archbishop Coakley Issues Urgent Call for Peace in the Middle East... Where Do Bishops Come From? The Divinely Appointed Overseer... German Bishops to Ask Rome to Permit Lay Homilies... This Sunday, Lent Transfigures Us... Brazilian Archbishop Declares Schism and Excommunications, Says TLM Attendees ‘Don’t Deserve Name of Christians or Catholics’... US and Israel Launch Attack on Iran... The American Catholic Philosophical Association at 100... Christopher Kaczor In 1926, Marilyn Monroe and Queen Elizabeth II were born. President Calvin Coolidge was in the White House, Pope Pius XI was in the Vatican, and Babe Ruth was in the World Series, hitting three home runs in a single game. Also in 1926, Fr. Edward A. Pace founded the American Catholic Philosophical Association... Sin is the monster in the room. Suffering is our personal encounter with it... Fr. Jerry Pokorsky In 1510, Dominican friars arrived in Santo Domingo and refused absolution to colonists who would not repent of their exploitation of the Indians. The refusal was not cruelty; it was spiritual medicine. Among those shaken was Bartolomé de las Casas, a landowner whose estates relied on forced Indian labor... Watch: Robot plays tennis with humans, returns shots with 96% accuracy... What the Vatican court ruling means for papal sovereignty, and Cardinal Becciu... Ed Condon Finding that prosecutors had no right to redact the findings of their original investigation into the London property scandal, the judges ordered effectively an unusual trial-within-an-appeal, opening up the original investigation and charges to new litigation. But even more seismic... Pray for Gina, and the Florida Feast... J.D. Flynn The big news out of the Vatican this morning is a report claiming that the sprawling financial trial that convicted Cardinal Angelo Becciu has been “overturned,” and that judges have ordered a “new trial.” But we’re not so sure that’s the right way to put things, or that it reflects the reality of a complicated legal decision. At The Pillar this morning... At the Tomb of Lazarus: A Reflection on the Fifth Sunday of Lent... Scott Hahn As we draw near to the end of Lent, today’s Gospel clearly has Jesus’ passion and death in view. That’s why John gives us the detail about Lazarus’ sister, Mary — that she is the one who anointed the Lord for burial. His disciples warn against returning to Judea; Thomas even predicts they will “die with Him” if they go back... Reports Emerge on Pope Leo XIV’s First Encyclical; La Repubblica Says Post-Easter Release Expected... Pope Leo Meets Gareth Gore, Author Urging Investigation of Opus Dei... Human or Divine? A Battle of the Wills... Marlon De La Torre One of the most fruitful challenges during the season of Lent, I argue, is the spiritual tension that develops between the desires of the human will versus assenting to the will of God. A reality of the journey toward spiritual discernment is the daily battle that ensues between following the will of God or ignoring it altogether for one’s own desires of the will... From Doo-Wop to Doctrine: Rock Legend Dion’s Musical Friendship With Mike Aquilina... Pope Questions Christians’ Role in Wars, Implies Need for Confession... Missed Masses, Marquesses, and Mullets... St. Gregory of Nazianzus Warns: Don’t Think Too Highly of Yourself... David Mills Don’t care about who gives you the sacraments of the Church, said the bishop. Don’t demand a cleric of high status in the Church and in society, because you think an everyday cleric from an average family isn’t good enough for someone of your high status. Don’t reject a priest unless you think he’s holy enough, because you think you’ll be sullied by receiving the sacraments from an average sinner... Pope Leo XIV Names Benedictine from St. Meinrad’s as Bishop of Belleville in Illinois... Death Is Not The End: Remembering Francis Bergsma... Faith and Science Are Not Enemies — and Young People Need to Hear It... Cardinal Mathieu, Archbishop of Tehran, Evacuated From Iran to Rome... Why Does Jesus Weep at the Tomb of Lazarus? Why Are Swiss Bishops Doubling Down on Mandatory Psych Screening? A 5-year-old boy was left alone in a hospital on the day of his heart surgery. His anesthesiologist adopted him... A Purgatorial Procession... A Confession of the Legendary Lou Holtz... Chaldean Bishop Shaleta Arrested at San Diego Airport on Charges of Embezzlement, Money Laundering... 4 Ways Pope Leo XIV Is the Augustinian Pope... Pope Leo XIV Announces March Prayer Intention: ‘For Disarmament and Peace’... St. John Vianney Said a Good Priest Could Lead 1,000 Souls to Heaven. I Think He Underestimated... The Cardinal of Penzance, and Camp Commandments... Treetops Emit Ultraviolet Sparkles During Thunderstorms. Researchers Just Filmed It in Nature for the First Time... Vatican Synod Study Group Warns of Online Polarization... Toy Story and AI Toys — Disney to the Rescue? Sin Is Not an Abstraction... New Israeli Land Reforms Raise Fears Among West Bank Christians... Every Round Goes Higher: A Homily for the Second Sunday of Lent... How to Write Well — and Why... Pope Leo XIV’s Sunday Angelus: ‘Only Peace, a Gift of God, Can Heal the Wounds Between Peoples’...