Letter 39: Blæsilla died within three months of her conversion, and Jerome now writes to Paula to offer her his sympathy and, if possible, to moderate her grief. He asks her to remember that Blæsilla is now in paradise, and so far to control herself as to prevent enemies of the faith from cavilling at her conduct. Then he concludes with the prophecy (since...

JeromePaula|c. 383 AD|jerome
education booksfamine plaguegrief deathillnessimperial politicsmonasticismproperty economicsslavery captivitywomen
Persecution or exile; Travel & mobility; Natural disaster/crisis
From: Jerome, priest and scholar in Rome
To: Paula, Roman noblewoman and ascetic
Date: ~384 AD
Context: A letter of consolation after the death of Paula's daughter Blaesilla, barely three months after her conversion — Jerome tries to moderate Paula's grief while honoring the young woman's extraordinary gifts.

Paula,

If only my head were a spring of water, my eyes a fountain of tears — not to weep, as Jeremiah did, for the slain of my people [Jeremiah 9:1], nor like Jesus over Jerusalem's fate [Luke 19:41], but for holiness itself, for innocence, for chastity, for every virtue that has died now that Blaesilla is gone. I do not grieve for her sake. I grieve for my own. My loss is more than I can bear calmly.

Who can remember, dry-eyed, the burning faith of a girl of twenty who raised the banner of the Cross and mourned the loss of her virginity more than the death of her husband? Who can forget the intensity of her prayers, the brilliance of her conversation, the tenacity of her memory, the quickness of her mind? If you heard her speak Greek, you would have thought she knew no Latin. If she switched to Latin, there was no trace of a foreign accent. She mastered Hebrew in a matter of weeks — not months — until she could match her own mother's skill in learning and singing the psalms.

Her dress was plain, but not as a badge of superiority. She dressed no better than her maids, and the only thing that set her apart was the ease of her bearing. Her body was wrecked by fasting — her steps unsteady, her face pale, her thin neck barely supporting her head — yet she always had a book of Scripture in her hand.

As she lay dying, her body scorched with fever and her family gathered around her, her last words were: "Pray to the Lord Jesus, that he may forgive me — because what I wanted to do, I was not able to finish." Rest in peace, Blaesilla. Your conversion came in time. The words to the dying thief on the cross are your guarantee: "Today you will be with me in paradise" [Luke 23:43].

But what am I doing? I set out to comfort a mother, and I am weeping myself. I make no secret of it: this entire letter is written in tears. Even Jesus wept for Lazarus [John 11:35]. But a comforter who is overcome by his own grief makes a poor counselor.

Paula, my anguish is as great as yours — Jesus knows it, and so do the holy angels, among whom Blaesilla now takes her place. I was her spiritual father, her foster-father in affection. Sometimes I cry out with Job: "Let the day perish on which I was born!" [Job 3:3]. And then I catch myself: "If I speak like this, I betray the faith of all God's children" [Psalm 73:15].

Here is the hard truth: do not grieve as though you have no hope [1 Thessalonians 4:13]. Tears for the dead are natural, but they must have a limit. Pagans weep without hope; we, who believe in the resurrection, should temper our sorrow. Excessive grief does not honor the dead — it punishes the living.

I must be blunt with you: your enemies are watching. The enemies of the faith are whispering that your grief proves Christianity is a fraud, that your daughter's fasting killed her, that the monks and their cruel discipline are to blame. They say: "No one stops this woman from weeping. She proves by her own despair that what we have always said is true — Christian asceticism is a death sentence." These are your daughter's enemies, and they wear the mask of sympathy.

You must not give them this weapon. When you weep without ceasing, when you refuse to eat, when you collapse at the funeral as though you wished to follow Blaesilla into the grave — the pagans take notice, and they rejoice. You owe it to your daughter's memory to show the world that Christian faith is stronger than death.

Think about where Blaesilla is now. She is not in the grave. She is with Christ. She is free from the broken body that tortured her at the end, free from the fever, free from the world's cruelty. She is among the saints, among the martyrs. She looks down from heaven and says to you: "Mother, why do you weep for me? I have what I longed for. Stop mourning. Your tears cannot reach me, but your faith can."

Consider the alternative. Would you rather she had lived a long life of worldly comfort, married again, borne children, grown old in luxury — and lost her soul? She traded a few years for eternity. That is not a loss. It is a victory.

You still have Eustochium, your virgin daughter, your consolation. You still have the community you have built, the monks and nuns who look to you for strength. And you will have Blaesilla's name — I promise you this, and it is a promise I intend to keep: wherever my writings go, Blaesilla will travel with them. Every page I write will carry her memory. Virgins, widows, monks, and priests will read her name and know what she was. In my work, she will never die.

As a childless widow, she will stand between her mother Paula and her sister Eustochium the virgin — not first, not last, but honored in her own place. In my writings, she will always be alive. She will hear me speaking of her, always, to her mother and her sister.

Modern English rendering for readability. See the 19th-century translation or original Latin/Greek for scholarly use.

Related Letters